• Solutions
    • Killer Sales Presentations
    • The Winning Proposal
    • Superior Sales Performance
    • Promote your Solutions
  • Services
    • For Business Leaders
    • For Sales
    • For Marketing
  • Why Quantum
    • Case Studies
    • Client Testimonials
  • Resource Center
  • Contact

Call us +44 (0)203 815 8020

hello@quantumigl.com
QuantumQuantum
  • Solutions
    • Killer Sales Presentations
    • The Winning Proposal
    • Superior Sales Performance
    • Promote your Solutions
  • Services
    • For Business Leaders
    • For Sales
    • For Marketing
  • Why Quantum
    • Case Studies
    • Client Testimonials
  • Resource Center
  • Contact

Why do we keep losing tenders?

Home NewsWhy do we keep losing tenders?
failing-tenders-better-luck-next-time

Why do we keep losing tenders?

Most companies that ask themselves the “why do we keep losing tenders?” question usually already have a pretty good idea of the answer. But – bizarrely – they keep on doing the same things anyway, and so keep on losing with their tenders, time after time.

When I became responsible for the success of the tenders at a healthcare provider we won just one out of the first 10 we submitted.  That win rate was totally unacceptable, but we were prepared to learn … and learn we did.

After those first 10 our win rate went to a rock solid one in every three. Since around 15 vendors tendered for every opportunity that we were involved in, our Board was satisfied with 1:3. We would, of course, have liked to have won everything we went for. But, realistically, you are never going to be that successful. In any case, your business would likely blow up under the strain of service delivery.

So why do so many companies tolerate win rates of 1:5 or worse? Perhaps there are two elements here:

Reasons-for-failing-tenders-and-not-winning

1. How much does it cost to tender?

The first reason for not evolving and continuing to lose tenders, which is highly pervasive in the market, is a profound ignorance of the total cost of tendering.

We strongly recommend that every business seeking to grow and win substantial new revenues by tendering is all over this number (because it will act as a bucket of ice cold water in the face. At first you will be shocked and then you will want to take speedy action to ease the pain).

Our outsourcing healthcare bids cost us £80,000 to £100,000 per bid against a total average contract value of around £6m pounds.

This equates to 1.3 – 1.7% of the contract value. So, even once we were winning one in three tenders it was costing us over £250,000 to secure £6m in revenue because we still lost two out of three. Therefore, our fully loaded cost of tendering was around 4% of the value of the deal that was successfully landed).

At first, we couldn’t believe these sorts of numbers ourselves, but when you factor in the time of everyone directly and indirectly involved in the tender, the bid effort is enormous; often over one man year’s worth of time (which necessarily includes the time of the MD, FD, CEO and other senior people if you are going to be serious about winning tenders).

2. We all live in hope

The second reason for continuing “same old, same old” is more to do with human nature and optimism. Isn’t is easier to sometimes stay deep inside our comfort zone and follow processes and methods that we are already familiar with rather than undertake potentially drastic changes?

Well, yes. In a sense, it can be easier to do same old, same old – but think of all the time and human effort that is being wasted. In the medium term, it will be easier to make the necessary changes and get your approach to tendering properly sorted. Plus, your business is going to be much more successful with the requisite changes in place.

So, what changes should you be considering?

Pick your battles very carefully – be ready to qualify out

The very, very hardest change is to sometimes make decisions that mean that you do nothing in connection with a major tender opportunity!

Too many Sales leaders get very excited whenever there’s an opportunity to tender. But before mobilising the team and spending tens or even hundreds of thousands on a tender exercise, get your cleverest people together to calmly assess the real chance of success.

There are many reasons why you should walk away right now for you next “big tender opportunity”, including a lack of relationship with the prospect, inability to deliver the required service or product, other pressing business priorities etc.

Ensure that you have your best people in the Bid vs No Bid review and use a formal tool to critically score your chances. Then it’s easy to decide whether you are going for this one or not.

Your tender documents look rubbish

The tender response may well be obliged to follow a prescribed sequence and cover huge amounts of technical detail. But are you falling into the trap of giving the immediate impression that your tender response is wordy and hard to read?

First impressions do count. If your document looks boring or bland or is too hard to read, your wonderful tender might get only a cursory treatment … even if the content is actually brilliant. In just the last few years, brilliant content is no longer enough. It must be beautifully served up too.

Badly-presented-tenders-help-you-lose-stop-you-winning

Your tender documents are rubbish

But how good is the content? Are you answering the RFP’s (Request for Proposal’s) questions directly and succinctly?

Cutting and pasting standard content from earlier bids might save your bid team time, but is this approach going to delight your readers and prospective customers? Err, no.

Break away from “cut and paste” and work to a new method that means that you are rigorously and directly addressing the needs of your prospect.

It’s not a proper team effort

The numbers above might have shocked you. Do your own analysis to understand precisely your own cost of tender. Then, if you are still a long way from our numbers (which tie in nicely with standard, reported tender costs) there might be another avenue to consider …

… are you relying too heavily of a small number of “bid heroes” – a dedicated Bid Manager and a Sales guy who flog themselves for weeks to get the bid over the line just in the nick of time?

These are the people that frequently fall sick once the bid is out of their hair – if you are lucky. If you are unlucky they’ll succumb to exhaustion sometime before the deadline and you will have to cover for them by pulling in resources that know nothing of the tender and have no appetite to get involved either.

Bid-Heroes-drowning-in-tender-work-stop-you-winning-tenders

Successful bids have clearly-named bid leaders and managers, but it’s always a team effort, with the winning team consisting of the appropriate domain experts, operational personnel and senior executives.

An orchestra would never ask the conductor to play the instruments too. So why should we expect the Bid Manager to do all or the lion’s share of the work?

This is where having a defined bid process with clear lines of responsibility and ownership comes in. Equipped with the appropriate systems and tools backing it, a streamlined, pragmatic tender process can really sing and dance for you.

And you might even find that staff sickness and absenteeism in the bid team improves as a consequence!

The Executive Summary fails to compel (or is non-existent)

If putting in a Bid vs. No Bid mechanism is the hardest thing to do (because the first step to improving win rates is the hardest one to take), the easiest way to make a massive and beneficial impact is to get your Executive Summary well-honed. (Anyone who has had any exposure to creating top-class proposals will know this already).

Use a concise and visually attractive Executive Summary to clearly state your agreed Win Themes using simple, audience-centric language.

Show your solution in the form of a simplified diagram. For those prepared to tackle your tender in full a strong Executive Summary sets the scene beautifully. For those who won’t / don’t read beyond Executive Summaries you have delivered the essence of your proposal very succinctly – and this will be much-appreciated by those with limited concentration spans!

Is that it?

No, but these are some of the fundamental building blocks that will make a substantial difference. You will want the best people in the mix, effective Account Managers, a brilliant presentation and team of convincing presenters for when you get shortlisted, but these are the real basics – the things to concentrate on first if you want to improve your tender win rates.

You may well be able to do some or all of this internally. If not, there are plenty of experts out there who will be delighted to help engineer beneficial change and support you in your business goals.

Summary

Summary-reasons-for-failing-tenders-and-not-winning-tenders

Could we help?

Quantum works with Sales and Marketing departments to develop more impactful and successful winning tenders and sales proposals.

If you would like to explore any if the ideas raising in this article we’d love to hear from you.

Tags: bidBid Heroesbid processcost of tendercost of tenderingLosing tenderstenderswin tenders

From the Blog

  • What’s in a Word? (Video)
    What’s in a Word? (Video) We appear to live in era where videos, presentations and...
    Read More
  • What’s in a Word? (Article)
    What’s in a Word? (Article) You can make profound changes to your sales conversion rates...
    Read More
  • Proposals and presentations
    Proposals and presentations “The sales proposals and presentations that they developed with us...
    Read More
  • How to Make a Business Video
    How to Make a Business Video Here we take a look at the things you should...
    Read More
  • Prospect says: “email me your proposal”. What should you do?
    Prospect says: “email me your proposal”. What should you do? Get Ready to Walk At the end of your sales...
    Read More

Twitter

  • Why words matter in sales. Use the best words to sell more.  http://t.co/mp4v2g1x3E   http://t.co/EY0ToSY4qd 
  • 1 year ago
  • Check out my latest article: Win More Proposals with the 7-Step Simple Bid Process  http://t.co/q76HtFVehS  via  @LinkedIn 
  • 3 years ago

Follow @QuantumIGL

Contact Us

We're currently offline. Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message

Testimonials

  • The sales proposals and presentations that they developed with us were outstanding … their role in delivering key sales wins in London and in the South West was absolutely invaluable

    Chief Commercial Strategy and Marketing Officer
    Health Tech
  • I am always impressed by his [Quantum Director’s] dedication to the client, eye for detail and his innovative ways of thinking. It’s great to have him on board!

    Managing Director
    Design Agency
  • In six weeks Quantum helped grow our funnel by £65m, £31m of which became closed business within four months – a fantastic achievement!

    Strategy and Marketing Director
    Care UK (Healthcare Provider)
  • I just closed one out of my two sales deals that we discussed on the course … I am very grateful for all I have learned … thank you from Switzerland.

    Sales Executive
    Global Fin Tech
  • [They’ve had] a major impact on the quality of the proposals submitted to clients and our final presentations, as well as helping define and improve our internal systems and processes.

    CEO
    Harmoni (Healthcare Provider)
  • These guys bring real rigour to developing top class, high value proposals … the results have been outstanding.

    Chief Executive Officer
    GTD Healthcare
  • [They undertook] a root and branch review of our sales function and recommend key improvements …  [plus] honed our sales messages and developed a new corporate sales presentation … throughout [we were] impressed [by their] … thoughtfulness, professionalism and dedication.

    Group Marketing Director
    Healthcare
  • A really strong presentation was going to be essential …  [they] … created a version that was visually very impressive … and thoroughly engaging for the audience … a job well done!

    EMEA Project Director
    Canon
  • I gained a tremendous amount from the workshop on how to structure and present

    Business Engagement Manager
    Major bank
  • [Quantum’s  director] is a strategic thinker and skilled facilitator … quick on his feet and able to command an audience. Highly professional and easy to work with … an asset to any organisation and someone I highly recommend.

    EMEIA Service Quality Lead
    Top 4 Consulting Firm
  • [They have] the ability to take complex ideas and simplify them – so that the audience quickly understands the benefits they will get from us.

    Programme Director and Bid Controller
    UK Health Tech

Most Recent

What’s in a Word? (Video)

What’s in a Word? (Video)

17th January 2022

Sell more by using better words. Compel your prospects to buy from you by harnessing the power of words. Be more positive and audience-centric in the way you use words in all sales interactions.

Social

© 2023 · Quantum International Group Ltd. All Rights Reserved

  • Solutions
  • Services For …
  • Why Quantum?
  • News
  • Privacy and Legal
  • Contact Quantum
  • Cookie Policy (UK)
Prev Next
Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}